Monday, March 10, 2025

Tyler Loses Two Sandwich Shops – What Happened?

Must read

Running your errands and driving around town, you pass by the same places over and over again. You pass by them so often that you don’t give them a second thought.

We take it for granted that a sandwich shop we visit from time to time is going to be there because it’s been there for at least 30 years.

Last week, while on my way into the radio station, I happened to notice two large yellow signs with black block lettering saying “Please visit our other 2 locations” in front of a sandwich shop that I enjoyed eating at on WSW Loop 323 in Tyler.

This sign was accompanied by another that read,

Schlotzsky’s CLOSED

Lucky Larry, Mix 93-1

Lucky Larry, Mix 93-1

The place with a funny name that serves up the serious sandwich suddenly closed down on Tyler‘s WSW Loop. No more small turkey bacon club. No more pepperoni pizza. No more medium The Original, please hold the black olives.

Gone. Just like that, overnight.

Of course, I drove through the parking lot looking at the building, and I noticed they were doing a lot of painting. I did a Google search of the Tyler locations, and this one says ‘temporarily closed’.

Lucky Larry, Mix 93-1

Lucky Larry, Mix 93-1

Hopefully, they’re doing some remodeling, but my gut feeling says no because they’ve removed all branding from the building and painted over their marquee sign.

Schlotzsky’s isn’t the only sandwich shop that recently closed in Tyler

Last weekend, on my way out of Tyler heading to Longview, I was on ESE Loop 323 approaching Troup Hwy. and noticed that another sandwich shop had gone out of business and removed the branding for its building, too.

The Subway that sat next to Texas Roadhouse is no longer there. I don’t know how long it’s been closed. Frankly, in my opinion, I was amazed it was open for as long as it was because it was in a weird location all by itself.

Don’t fret, sandwich lovers; there are options

Schlotzsky’s still has two locations in Tyler

  • 2105 SSE Loop 323
  • 709 S Beckham

Subway still has more than 15 locations, and McAlister’s recently opened a new location on Old Jacksonville Hwy.

So, there’s still plenty of places to pick up a sandwich, but nothing will beat that sourdough bread and pizza from Schlotzsky’s.

If you have any details on this location, please email me and let me know, and then I’ll update this article if the information can be made public, of course!

The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Tyler, TX? Local People Chime in

Wondering where to get the best sandwiches in the Tyler, Texas area? Well, local people recently kindly chimed in on a Facebook social media group page.

Gallery Credit: Tara Holley

Where to Get the Best Sandwiches Around Tyler

If you’re looking for a fantastic sandwich around Tyler here is what the locals suggest.

Gallery Credit: Billy Jenkins

The Greatest Fake Pork Sandwich has Returned in All Its Glory, the McRib

Once a year, McDonald’s gives me a reason to visit outside of breakfast, the McRib. After its farewell tour last year, the sandwich has made a glorious return.

Gallery Credit: Michael Gibson / Townsquare Media

Latest article